Chinese Immigration:
Origins and Opinions

 

 

Biographies 

Pro-Exclusion:

Dennis Kearney

Dennis Kearney.  Photo Courtesy of Spartacus Educational.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Prominent Leader of the Workingman's Party in the West, Kearney coined the slogan the "The Chinese Must Go!"  He felt the Chinese robbed white men of their jobs in the United States because these recent immigrants worked for such low wages.  Kearney even campaigned in the east coast to rally support for his cause. 
For more information on Dennis Kearney go to these sites:
"Our Misery and Despair":  Kearney Blasts Chinese Immigration

Kearneyism in California

Kearneyism, the Chinese, and Labor Unrest

"You Sabe Him?"  Kealney Must Go!"

"The Sandlot and Kearnyism"

The Kearney - Kalloch Epoch

 

 

 

 

                                                                  

Henry George

Henry George.  Photo Courtesy of 
Robert Schalkenbach Foundation.

 

 

Author of Progress and Poverty, this transplanted San Francisco businessman opposed Chinese immigration.  His reasons mirrored those of Kearney in the terms of disliking the Chinese because they worked for cheap wages and took American jobs, but George also believed the Chinese would never be able to assimilate into American Society. For more information on Henry George visit:
Who was Henry George?

 

 

 

 

James Blaine

James Blaine.  Photo Courtesy of Biographical Directory of the 
United States Congress.
Republican Representative and Senator from Maine, Blaine was one of the only Congressmen to support Chinese immigration restriction east of the Rockies.  He believed by supporting immigration restriction would help him gain support from westerners for the 1876 and 1880 presidential nominations.  Blaine also championed the Fifteen Passengers Bill for Chinese immigration restriction, but this bill was eventually vetoed by President Hayes. For more information on Blaine visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

 

 

John Franklin Miller

John Franklin Miller.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

 

 


A Republican Senator from California, this man was one of the first men to crack under the pressure his constituents put on him about implementing Chinese exclusion.  During the forty-seventh session of Congress, in 1882, Senator Miller introduced a bill to suspend the immigration of Chinese laborers to the United States for a period of twenty years.   President Arthur vetoed this bill, but passed the second bill Miller proposed including an exclusionary period of only ten years.  For more information on Miller visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

 


 

John Percival Jones

John Percival Jones.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
A Republican Senator from Nevada, this man supported the Chinese Exclusion Act because he believed the intermingling of races did not work.  He stated" We oppose their coming because out sturdy Aryan tree will wither in root, trunk, and branch, if this noxious vine be permitted to entwine itself around it."  The noxious vine Jones is referring to is the Chinese.  For more information on Jones visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

 

 

 

 

John Tyler Morgan

John Tyler Morgan.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of  the United States Congress.

A Democratic Senator from Alabama, Morgan supported exclusion because he feared the Chinese would team up with African-Americans and destroy American society.  He stated, "It has become the solemn necessity on our part to protect the Caucasian race on this continent against the intrusion of Oriental people."  For more information on Morgan visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress .

 

Edwin Willits
(no picture available)

 

 

 

A Republican Representative from Michigan, Willits supported Chinese exclusion in the name of the workingmen.  He stated, "My chief reason for supporting such a measure is that I believe in the interest of American labor."  For more information on Willits visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress

 

Anti-Exclusion:

Hannibal Hamlin

Hannibal Hamlin.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
Republican Representative from Maine, Hamlin opposed Chinese exclusion because he felt the bill went against the American ideal of equal rights for all men.
For more information about Hamlin visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

 

 

 

 

 

 

George Frisbie Hoar

George Frisbie Hoar.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Senate.

A Republican Representative and Senator from Massachusetts. he took the leadership role for those who were opposed to Chinese exclusion in Congress.  Like Hamlin, he believed Chinese immigration restriction opposed the doctrine of equal rights for all men.  For more information about Hoar visit:
The Biographical Directory to the United States Congress.
 

 

Henry Dawes

Henry Dawes.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

A Republican Representative and Senator from Massachusetts, Dawes was a prominent adversary of Chinese exclusion.  He asserted, "the right of emigration belonged to all humanity and the political organization which I am proud to belong to, was summoned into existence to the very purpose of vindicating the equality of the human race upon this continent in all political rights."  For more information on Dawes visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Senate.
 

 

Joseph Brown

Joseph Brown.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

A Democratic Senator from Georgia, Brown was against Chinese exclusion because he believed the United States could profit from Chinese goods and expanding the market to the Far East.  He stated, "China is a vast field open to commerce which ought to be great for white men's energy, thrift, and gain."  For more information on Brown visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress. 

 

Elbridge Lapham

Elbridge Lapham.  Photo Courtesy of the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
A Representative and Senator from New York,  Lapham opposed the Chinese Exclusion Act for much the same reasons as Senator Brown.  Lapham believed the Act would destroy the America's growing commerce in China, which he felt would be of great importance to the industrial and financial interests of the United States.  For more information about Lapham visit:
The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
 

 

Mark Twain

Mark Twain.  Photo Courtesy of weta.org.  

 

 

 

 

Mark Twain was one of the leading supporters for Asian immigration to the United States.  Alteration of the Burlingame Treaty limiting Chinese immigration to the United States greatly angered Twain.  He believed the Chinese were as able bodied as any American and respected those Chinese who entered the United States as evidenced in this passage:
Mark Twain's Observations about Chinese Immigrants in California.

Twain was also appalled by the treatment the Chinese received in the United States.  You can read Twains feeling in his article to The Galaxy:
"Disgraceful Persecution of a Boy"

 

 

 

      

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Created by Jaime Boyle
Graduate Student at American University

History in the Digital Age
Professor Robert Griffith
jaime_boyle@hotmail.com

Last Updated 12/06/03