THEORY
OF CONFLICT, VIOLENCE AND WAR
33.610.01
SUMMER 2001
MONDAY 5:30
- 8:40 PM
WEDNESDAY
5:30 - 8:40 PM
Dr Michael
Salla
Office: Room
310, SIS Building
Phone: (202)
885 1497
Email: msalla@american.edu
http://www.american.edu/salla/
Office
Hours:
Monday 4:30
- 5:30 pm
Wednesday
4:30 - 5:30 pm
Course
Description
This course
analyses a range of scholarly approaches to understanding conflict, violence
and war in the post-Cold War era. Distinctive themes and ideas in explanations
for the sources of conflict, violence and war will be identified in order
to develop effective strategies for responding to the latter. Students
will be introduced to theories ranging from the individual to the civilizational,
and to methodological debates concerning the appropriate level of analysis
for understanding sources of conflict. The course will adopt an integrative
approach that synthesize all levels of analysis but with particular emphasis
on those theories which help explain the internal conflicts which form
the prevalent sources of international conflict and violence in the post-cold
war era. At the end of the course, students should have a firm understanding
of the ways conflict, violence and war are conceptualized; and an appreciation
of some of the problems confronting attempts to develop effective strategies
for responding to international conflict, violence and war.
Course
Requirements and Evaluation
1. Class
Participation - 20%
Your participation
will be graded on the basis of three criteria: clarity; content; and context.
Clarity refers to whether your comments are clear, coherent and comprehensible.
Are you making yourself understood? Content refers to the substance of
your remarks. Are your comments thoughtful, well-informed and to the point?
Context refers to how well you integrate your comments with issues pertinent
to the course or to ongoing class discussion. Do you build upon what others
have said either by agreeing or disagreeing with them? Are you relating
discussion to issues raised in the readings?
Class discussion
comes more easily for some people than for others. By temperament or habit,
some are 'talkers' while others are 'listeners'. Learn to be both. An old
Ghanian proverb says that 'we have two ears and one mouth, learn to use
them in proportion!' If you are a 'talker', learn to give enough space
for others to speak. If a 'listener', try to participate more in discussions
even if this means asking questions. Intelligent questioning is just as
important as thoughtful commenting!
2. Reflective
Papers 30%
You are to
complete five reflective papers of between 500-750 words that examines
the readings offered for each level of analysis offerred in the course.
Note this is approximately one report per week and one report per level
of analysis with the exception of the first level analysis which requires
two reading reports. Due dates cover the readings from the last submission
up to and including the reading for the due date. Dates are July 9;
July 16; July 23, July 30, Aug 8. The reflective papers should not
be a detailed summary of the readings but should instead be a personal
response in terms of how the readings have (or have not!) contributed to
your own understanding of the sources of conflict, violence and war. Your
paper needs to show some evidence that you have read most if not all of
the set readings. In writing your reflective paper, you need to explicity
consider the following questions.
-
•How did the readings
assist my understanding of the sources of conflict, violence & war?
-
•What was my favorite
article(s) from that week's reading. Why? What issues did it discuss that
had particular resonance with me.
-
•In what way did
my favorite article relate to the other readings?
-
•What was the
least informative article(s). Why?
-
•What personal
experience or topical events relate to the theory of conflict, violence
and war advanced in the readings?
Note that reflective
papers will be graded. Papers scoring less than a B+ can be resubmitted
for a maximum of B+. You need to complete all reflective papers.
3.
Group Presentations - 20%
You are required
to form groups of two to give presentations incorporating the theories
and perspectives you believe most appropriate for describing a recent case
of international conflict, violence or war. You must attempt to interpret
the relevance of your case study and the conclusions you draw for conflict,
violence and war in the 21st century. Your group is expected to distribute
a two page summary to the class during the presentation. Assessment will
be based on the quality of your presentation and summary.
4.
End of Term Paper - 30%
A list of questions
will be handed out to the class dealing with particular problems concerning
conflict, violence and war. Each paper should critically question the literature
in terms of diverging approaches and perspectives taken by scholars in
addressing the question. (Note: suggestions for essay writing appear at
the end of this syllabus.) Papers should be between 12-15 double spaced
pages, fully referenced & including a bibliography, and handed
in on August 6.
Note: You are
expected to submit a two page outline of your planned paper on July
25. The outline should explicitly state your main argument in
response to the question. The outline should be broken down into section
headings with a brief description of what you expect each section to cover.
You need to use prose to explain the framework you use rather than just
provide a series of numbered headings which give me little idea of whether
your essay is descriptive, analytical or indeed even answers the question.
You should also include a bibliography of at least eight books/articles
that you will use for the essay. Remember, the outline is intended to get
you thinking in advance of the issues that you will be investigating, and
of developing an argument and framework that will give your essay coherence.
The more work you put into it, the easier it will be for more to identify
any potential problem areas and to give you constructive suggestions.
Required
Texts
-
Michael Brown,
ed. Theories of War and Peace (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1998)
-
Jo Groebel &
Robert Hinde, eds., Aggression and War (Cambridge University
Press, 1989)
-
Rush Dozier, Fear
Itself: The Origin and Nature of the Powerful Emotion That Shapes Our Lives
and Our World (New York: St Martin's Press, 1998)
-
Foreign Affairs
Agenda, The New Shape of World Politics: Contending Paradigms in International
Relations (New York: Foreign Affairs, 1997)
-
Kalevi Holsti,
The State, War, and the State of War (Cambridge University Press,
1996)
-
Chester Crocker,
Fen Osler Hampson & Pamela Aall, Managing Global Chaos: Sources
of and Responses to International Conflict (Washington, DC.: US Institute
of Peace, 1996)
-
Jennifer Turpin & Lester Kurtz, The Web of Violence
(University of Illinois Press, 1997)
Note:
Course Reserve Material is available on the American University Electronic
Resrve System or go directly to http://eresau.wrlc.org
The password is SALLA610 (the system is case sensitive).
CLASS
SCHEDULE
July 2 Introduction:
Methodological Approaches to the Study of Violence, Conflict and War in
the Post-Cold War Era
-
Jack S. Levy,
"Contending Theories of International Conflict: A Levels-of-Analysis Approach,"
Managing Global Conflict, eds. Crocker, et al., 3-24
-
Turpin & Kurtz,
"Introduction: Violence - The Micro/Macro Link," The Web of Violence,
1-28
-
Holsti, The State, War, and the State of War 1-40
CASE
STUDY: ISRAEL PALESTINE
July 4 Independence
Day - No Class
I.
First Image - Individual Sources
July 9 The
Psychological Bases of Violence
-
R.D. Laing, The Divided Self, 65-77; 94-105
Further
Reading
-
Deepak Chopra,
Ageless Body, Timeless Mind: A practical alternative to growing old
(London:
Rider, 1993) 3-40
July 11 Hatred
& Aggression
-
Konrad Lorenz, On Aggression, (New York: Bantam Books,
1973) 20-53
-
Sigmund Freud
& Albert Einstein, "Why War," The Pelican Freud Library (New
York: Viking Penguin, 1985) Vol 12, 341-62
-
Erich Fromm, The
Anatomy of Human Destructiveness (New York: Holt, Rinehart &Winston,
1973) 218-67
-
R.A. Hinde &
J. Groebel, "The problem of aggression," in Aggression and War,
3-10
-
Jeffrey Goldstein,
"Beliefs about human aggression," in Aggression and War, 11-20
-
P. Basteson, Is
aggression instinctive?" in Aggression and War, 35-47
Further
Reading
Video:
Beyond Hate: The Heart of Hatred
July 16
Frustration & Fear
-
John Dollard,
Frustration and Aggression, 1939, 1-26
-
Rush Dozier, Fear
Itself: The Origin and Nature of the Powerful Emotion That Shapes Our Lives
and Our World (New York: St Martin's Press, 1998) chs. 1, 4, 11, 12
-
Abraham Maslow, Motivation & Personality, 3rd
ed. (NY: Harper & Row, 1987) 15-31,56-61 (http://psychclassics.vorku.ca/Maslow/motivation.htm)
-
Ted Robert Gurr, Why Men Rebel (Princeton UP, 1970)
22-58
Further
Reading
-
Walter Korpi,
"Conflict, Power and Relative Deprivation," American Political Science
Review 68:4 (1974) 1569-1578 [online access through AU library's electronic
texts section]
-
Roger Coate &
Jerel Rosati, "Human Needs in World Society," The Power of Human Needs
in World Society, eds., Roger Coate & Jerel Rosati, 1-20
-
Seyom Brown, The
Causes and Prevention of War, 29-47
-
Terry Boswell
& William Dixon, "Marx's Theory of Rebellion," American Sociological
Review 58:5 (1993): 681-702 [online access through AU library's electronic
texts section]
-
Knud Larsen, Aggression:
Myths and Models (Chicago: Nelson-Hall, 1976) 57-75
II.
Second Image - Societal Sources
July 18
Cultural Violence & Dehumanization of the Enemy
-
Jacob Rabbie,
"Group processes as stimulants of aggression," in Aggression and War,
141-55
-
K. Lagerspetz,
"Media and the social environment," in Aggression and War, 164-73
-
Cultural factors,
"biology and human aggression, in Aggression and War, 173-88
-
Robert Elias,
"A Culture of Violent Solutions," in the Web of Violence, 117-48
-
Riane Eisler,
"Human Rights and Violence: Integrating the Private and Public Sphere,"Web
of Violence, 162-85
-
Johan Galtung,
Peace by Peaceful Means, 196-210
-
Janice Gross Stein,
"Image, Identity, and Conflict Resolution," Managing Global Chaos,
eds., Crocker, et al., 93-112.
Video: Faces
of the Enemy
Further
Reading
-
Vamik Volkan,
"An Overview of Psychological Concepts Pertinent to Interethnic and/or
International Relationships," The Psychodynamics of International Relationships
(Lexington
Books, 1990) 31-46
-
Demetrios A. Julius,
"The Genesis and Perpetuation of Aggression in International Conflicts"
The Psychodynamics of International Relationships (Lexington Books,
1990) 97-110
-
Rafael Moses,
"On Dehumanizing the Enemy," The Psychodynamics of International Relationships
(Lexington Books, 1990) 111-18
-
Robert Rieber
and Robert Kelly, 'Substance and Shadow: Images of the Enemy,' in The
Psychology of War and Peace. The Image of the Enemy, ed. Robert Rieber
(New York: Plenum, 1991) 3-40
-
Arun Swamy, "Nationalist
Ideologies and Misperceptions in Indo-US Relations," Foreign Policy in
Focus. Special Report March 20, 2000.
http://www.foreignpolicy-infocus.org/papers/india/index.html
-
•Daniel Pipes,
"Is Russia Still an Enemy," Foreign Affairs 76:5 (1997): 65-78
-
Joseph Monteville,
"The Psychological Roots of Ethnic and Sectarian Terrorism," The Psychodynamics
of International Relationships (Lexington Books, 1990) 163-80
July 23 Ethnic
Nationalism, Authoritarianism & Failed States
-
Holsti, The State, War and the State of War, 61-122
Stephen Van Evera,
"Hypotheses on Nationalism and War, in Theories of War and Peace,
257-91
David Lake &
Donald Rothchild, "Containing Fear: The Origins and Management of Ethnic
Conflict," in Theories of War and Peace, 292-328
Ted Robert Gurr,
"Minorities, Nationalists, and Ethnopolitical Conflict," Managing Global
Chaos, eds., Crocker, et al., 53-78
Mark N. Katz,
"Collapsed Empires," Managing Global Chaos, eds., Crocker, et al.,
25-36
John M. Owen,
"How Liberalism Produces Democratic Peace," in Theories of War and Peace,
137-75
Further
Reading
-
Fareed Zakaria,
"The Rise of Illiberal Democracy," Foreign Affairs 76:6 (1997):
22-43
-
Michael Doyle,
"Liberalism and World Politics," in The New Shape of World Politics,
-
Christopher Layne,
"Kant or Cant: The Myth of the Democratic Peace," in Theories of War
and Peace, 176-220
-
Philip Smith,
"Civil Society & Violence," The Web of Violence, eds., Turpin
& Kurtz, 91-116
-
Edward Mansfield
& Jack Snyder, "Democratization and the Danger of War, in Theories
of War and Peace, 221-256
-
Mohammed Ayoob,
"State Breaking, and State Failure," ," Managing Global Chaos, eds.,
Crocker, et al., 37-51.
-
Francis Underhill,
"Where Does Violence Come," American Diplomacy 3:3 (1998).
http://www.unc.edu/depts/diplomat/archives/arcframe.html
•P. Sahadevan,
"Ethnic Conflict and Militarism in South Asia," Occasional Paper #16, Kroc
Institution, http://www.nd.edu/~krocinst/sahadevan.pdf
•Fred W. Riggs,
"Turmoil Among Nations," Injustice Studies 1:1 (November 1997)
http://wolf.its.ilstu.edu/injustice/
•Anthony Baird,
"An Atmosphere of Reconciliation: A Theory of Resolving Ethnic Conflicts
Based on the Transcaucasian Conflicts," Online Journal of Peace and
Conflict Resolution (August 1999), http://www.trinstitute.org/ojpcr/2_4baird.htm
Donald Horowitz,
Ethnic Groups in Conflict (University of California Press, 1985)
3-12
Jurgen Habermas,
Legitimation Crisis (Boston: Beacon Press, 1975) 1-31, 45-50
C. Ellison &
J. Bartkowski, "Religion and the Legitimation of Violence," The Web
of Violence, eds. Turpin & Kurtz, 46-67
Francis Fukuyama,
"The End of History," in The New Shape of World Politics, 1-25
Marc F. Plattner,
"Liberalism and Democracy: Can't Have One Without the Other,"
Foreign
Affairs 77:2 (1998) 171-80
Joshua Muravchik,
"Promoting Peace Through Democracy," Managing Global Chaos, eds.,
Crocker, et al., 573-86
Charles A. Kupchan,
et al. "Illiberal Illusions: Restoring Democracy's Good Name"
Foreign
Affairs, 77:3 (1998)122-28
Fareed Zakaria,
"Culture Is Destiny: A Conversation with Lee Kuan Yew," in The New Shape
of World Politics, 219-33
Kim Dae Jung,
"Is Culture Destiny: The Myth of Asia's Anti-Democratic Values," in The
New Shape of World Politics, 234-41
Immanuel Kant,
Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay (New York, The Liberal Arts
Press, 1948) 1-52
III.
Third Image - International Sources
July 25
Term Paper Outline Due
July 25
The Westphalian State System & Weapons Proliferation
-
John Mearsheimer,
"Back to the Future: Instability in Europe after the Cold War," in
Theories
of War and Peace, 3-54
-
Charles Glaser,
"Realists as Optimists: Cooperation as Self-Help," in Theories of War
and Peace, 94-136
-
John Gerard Ruggie,
"The False Premise of Realism," in Theories of War and Peace, 407-16
-
J.David Singer,
The political origins of international war: a multifactorial review, in
Theories
of War and Peace, 202-29
-
•Stephen Van Evera,
"Offence, Defence, and the Causes of War," in Theories of War and Peace,
55-93
-
Geoffrey Kemp,
"Military Technology and Conflict," Managing Global Chaos, eds.,
Crocker, et al., 129-40
-
Alex Roland, "Technology
and War," American Diplomacy 2:2 (1997).
http://www.unc.edu/depts/diplomat/archives/arcframe.html
Video: To
be announced
Further
Reading
-
Richard Betts,
The New Threat of Mass Destruction, Foreign Affairs 77:1 (1998):
26-41
-
John Steinburner,
"Biological Weapons: A Plague Upon all Houses," Foreign Policy 109
(Winter 1997-98): 85-112
-
William Keller
& Janne Nolan, "The Arms Trade: Business As Usual," Foreign Policy
109 (Winter 1997-98): 112-25
-
Brown, The
Causes and Prevention of War, 2nd ed. (New York: St Martin's Press,
1994)82-99
July
30 International Trade
-
Dale Copeland,
"Economic Interdependence and War: A Theory of Trade Expectations," in
Theories of War and Peace, 464-501
-
Paul Krugman,
"Competitiveness: A Dangerous Obsession," in The New Shape of World
Politics, 161-76
-
Edward Luttwark,
"From Geopolitics to Geo-Economics: Logic of Conflict, Grammar of Commerce,"
in The New Shape of World Politics, 177-86
-
Theodore H. Moran,
"Trade and Investment Dimensions of International Conflict,"
Managing
Global Chaos, eds., Crocker, et al., 155-72
-
Richard E. Bissell,
"The Resource Dimension of International Conflict," Managing Global
Chaos, eds., Crocker, et al., 141-55
-
Paul Krugman,
"Workers and Economists I: First Do No Harm," in The New Shape of World
Politics, 206-13
IV.
Fourth Image - Global Sources
August 1
Global Population Explosion & the Environment
-
Thomas F. Homer-Dixon,
Environmental Scarcities and Violent Conflict: Evidence from Cases, in
Theories of War and Peace,501-36
-
John Orme, "The
Utility of Force in a World of Scarcity," in Theories of War and Peace,
-
Astri Suhrke,
"Environmental Change, Migration, and Conflict: A Lethal Feedback Dynamic?"
in Managing Global Chaos, 113-28
Video: World War
III - the Population Explosion on the Planet
August
6 International Conspiracy Theories, UFO's & Secret Government
-
•Executive Summary
of Disclosure Project Briefing Document, http://www.disclosureproject.org/PDF-Documents/ExecSummaryNOdocs.pdf
(Note: this is in PDF File) http://www.disclosureproject.org/Word-Documents/ExecutiveSummary-NOdocs.doc
(Note: This is in Word 2000 format)
-
•John Mack, Abduction:
Human Encounters with Aliens, New York: Ballantine, 19941-36
-
•http://www.abductee.net/index.html
(read levels 5 & 7, click left icons to go through each level)
-
•Richard Boylan,
UFO REALITY SHIFT?: Governments may soon break fifty years of silence to
tell us the truth about UFOs visiting our planet. But will they tell the
whole truth...? Nexus Magazine, Volume 3, #3 (April-May 1996). http://www.mt.net/~watcher/boylan2.html
-
•Milton William
Cooper, The UFO Conspiracy, Speech at "Whole Life Expo", Los Angeles, November
17, 1989 http://ebe.allwebco.com/Sections/GovernmentCoverups/Archive/ufoconspiracy.shtml
-
•Robert Dean,
Former NATO staffer Robert Dean speaks out on UFOs" Perceptions Magazine,
May/June 2000 http://ebe.allwebco.com/Sections/GovernmentCoverups/Archive/shape.shtml
-
•Johsua David
Stone, Hidden Mysteries: ET's, Ancient Mystery Schools and Ascension
(Sedona, Arizona, Light Technology Publishing, 1995) 1-18
-
•Patricia Pereira,
Eagles of a New Dawn, 25-29, 74-77
Further
Reading
•Sheldan
Nidle, Your First Contact (Pukalani, HI.: Blue Lodge Press, 2000)
263 -318
Video: www.connectlive.com/events/disclosureproject/
August 6
Term Paper Due
August 8
The Emergence of a New Civilizational Consciousness
-
Pitirim Sorokin,
The Basic Trends of Our Times (New Haven, CONN.: College & University
Press, 1964) 13-62
-
Michael Salla,
"Political Islam & the West: A New Cold War or Convergence?" Third
World Quarterly 18:4 (1997): 729-742
-
James Redfield,
The Celestine Vision (New York: Warner Books, 1997) 207-34
-
Lia Shapiro, From
Out of the Light a New World is Forming,
http://www.spiritweb.org/Spirit/new-world-lia.html
-
Patricia Pereira,
Eagles of a New Dawn, 201-17
-
W.T. Samsel, The
Atlantis Connection (Sedona, Arizona: Starfire Publishing, 1998) vii-xii,
73-88, 197-207
Further
Reading
-
Samuel Huntington,
"Clash of Civilizations," in The New Shape of World Politics,
67-91
-
Johan Galtung,
"Is there a Therapy for Pathological Cosmologies," The Web of Violence,
eds., Turpin & Kurtz, 188-205
-
Fouad Ajami, "The Summoning," in The New Shape of World
Politics, 92-100
David Little,
"Religious Militancy," Managing Global Chaos, eds., Crocker, et
al., 79-92
Ali Mazrui, Islamic
and Western Values, Foreign Affairs 76:5 (1998): 118-32
Jeff Haynes, "Religion,
secularisation and politics: a postmodern conspectus,"Third World Quarterly
18:4 (1997): 709-28
C. Ellison &
J. Bartkowski, "Religion and the Legitimation of Violence," The Web
of Violence, eds. Turpin & Kurtz, 46-67
M.E.Salla, Islamic
Radicalism & the West
-
Samuel Huntington,
The Clash of Civilizations and the remaking of world order (New
York: Simon Shuster, 1996)
-
Johan Galtung,
Peace by Peaceful Means, 211-24
SUGGESTIONS
FOR ESSAY WRITING
The essence
of good essay writing is to be found in the quality of your argument and
the level of analysis. The essay must go beyond description and narrative.
It is not enough just to tell a story, nor is it enough just to produce
a large number of facts related to the topic of your essay, nor is it enough
to merely recount what the authors of the textbooks have to say about the
topic. The essay should represent your considered perspective and your
informed thoughts on the problem you have been asked to write about. Of
course, you cannot begin to construct a considered perspective or develop
informed thoughts unless you first have a firm understanding of the subject
matter. So the first step is reading intensively and acquiring a grasp
of both the factual material and the arguments, debates, and differences
between those scholars who have contributed to the literature on the subject.
Having done that, you are then in a position to analyze the issue and develop
your own argument.
An argument,
in its basic sense, is a statement, supported by adequate empirical evidence
or logical inference, which addresses the question and presents a point
of view or a perspective on that question. The quality of the argument
will be measured by how persuasive it is, and its persuasiveness will be
a function of the skill with which you have constructed that argument.
Once you have
chosen your essay topic (or perhaps even as part of the process of choosing
your topic) it is helpful for you to begin by thinking about what the question
means and what you are being asked to do. Eventually this will become 'second
nature' to you, but you might think about approaching the task in this
way. Here is an example of how you might analyze a question in Peace and
Conflict Resolution.
'Does the notion
of 'structural violence' lead to a welcome extension to our understanding
of peace or does it introduce unwelcome ambiguities?
First, you
should identify the broad topic or subject of the question (this may seem
obvious but it is a good starting point). In the example given, the broadly
defined topic is - 'peace'.
Second, you
need to identify the more specific focus of the question - in this case,
the focus is the relationship between 'structural violence' and 'peace'.
Third, you
need to think carefully about any directions you are given in the question.
For example, here you are being asked whether structural violence leads
'to a welcome extension' or introduces 'unwelcome ambiguities' to our understanding
of peace. Your answer might be yes to the first part of the question (in
which case you would have to say why), and no to the second part (and again,
you would have to say why).
Remember that
at all times you will need to support your answer with an argument, rather
than simply making assertions. The more complex your argument, provided
it is clearly outlined, the more likely you will exhibit the necessary
analytical sophistication and creativity necessary for a high grade.